ALL TIME ALL-CITY PLAYERS LISTED ALPHABETICALLY
| year | last name | first | pos | ht | wt | class | paper | note |
| 1979 | Adams | Steve | LB | 5-11 | 210 | Sr. | Courier & Press | Both papers Unanimous Selection |
| 1993 | Ames | Brad | OG | 5-11 | 210 | Sr. | Courier & Press | Both papers |
| 1992 | Ames | Scott | OT | 6-0 | 260 | Sr. | Courier & Press | Both papers |
| 1977 | Andress | Jeff | DB | 5-11 | 170 | Jr. | Courier | Honorable Mention |
| 1978 | Andress | Jeff | DB | 5-11 | 170 | Sr. | Courier | |
| 1990 | Armstead | Karl | RB | 5-7 | 146 | Sr. | Courier & Press | Both papers |
| 1973 | Arrick | Greg | DB | Sr. | Press | Honorable Mention | ||
| 1966 | Atherton | Doug | RB | 5-10 | 160 | Sr. | Courier & Press | Both papers |
| 1995 | Bailey | Tom | WR | 6-1 | 165 | Sr. | Courier | |
| 1963 | Bargo | Ken | FB | 5-10 | 175 | So. | Courier & Press | Both papers + All SIAC |
| 1964 | Bargo | Ken | FB | 5-11 | 175 | Jr. | Courier & Press | Both papers |
| 1965 | Bargo | Ken | FB | 5-11 | 185 | Sr. | Courier | |
| 1995 | Barnes | Nick | P | 5-10 | 180 | Jr. | Courier & Press | Both papers |
| 1996 | Barnes | Nick | P | 5-11 | 190 | Sr. | Courier & Press | Both Papers 38.4 yd avg. |
| 1961 | Baugh | David | OT | 6-2 | 234 | Sr. | Press | Honorable Mention |
| 1974 | Baumeyer | Dean | OT | Sr. | Press | Honorable Mention | ||
| 2002 | Beck | Jeff | DB | 5-9 | 170 | Sr. | Courier | |
| 2001 | Bell | James | DL | 5-11 | 200 | Sr. | Courier | |
| 1987 | Berry | Chris | K | 6-0 | 170 | Jr. | Press | |
| 1988 | Berry | Chris | DB | 6-0 | 175 | Sr. | Courier & Press | Both papers |
| 1958 | Beshear | Bill | OE | 6-0 | 162 | Jr. | Courier & Press | Both papers |
| 1959 | Beshear | Bill | OE | 6-0 | 162 | Sr. | Press | Honorable Mention |
| 1995 | Beverly | William | CB | 5-10 | 195 | Jr. | Press | |
| 1994 | Blalock | Bart | OT | 6-4 | 245 | Jr. | Courier & Press | Both papers |
| 1995 | Blalock | Bart | OT | 6-5 | 265 | Sr. | Courier | |
| 1980 | Bledso | Rick | LB | 5-11 | 185 | So. | Courier | 2nd Team |
| 1995 | Branch | David | LB | 6-3 | 195 | Sr. | Press | |
| 1985 | Brown | David | LB | 6-1 | 190 | Sr. | Courier & Press | Both papers |
| 1963 | Broyles | Charlie | OG | 6-1 | 180 | Sr. | Courier & Press | Both papers + All SIAC |
| 1958 | Bruner | Jerry | OT | 5-9 | 220 | Jr. | Courier | Honorable Mention |
| 1959 | Bruner | Jerry | OT | 5-10 | 220 | Sr. | Courier & Press | Both papers |
| 1958 | Buck | Bill | QB | 5-9 | 162 | Sr. | Courier | Honorable Mention |
| 1977 | Burks | Randy | C | 6-5 | 205 | Sr. | Courier & Press | Both papers |
| 1999 | Bushrod | Derenzo | RB | 5-8 | 175 | Jr. | Courier | Special Mention |
| 2000 | Bushrod | Derenzo | RB | 5-8 | 175 | Sr. | Courier | All Metro Player of the Year |
| 1990 | Carey | Matt | DL | 5-11 | 225 | Sr. | Press | |
| 1986 | Carl | Marc | OG | 6-1 | 210 | Sr. | Courier & Press | Both papers |
| 1982 | Carl | Mike | K | 6-0 | 180 | Sr. | Courier | 2nd Team |
| 1964 | Chase | Bill | OG | 5-10 | 165 | Sr. | Courier | 2nd Team |
| 2009 | Clements | Cameron | LB | 5-11 | 220 | Sr. | Courier | |
| 2005 | Clements | Chris | DL | 5-9 | 205 | Sr. | Courier | |
| 1966 | Conley | George | C | 6-3 | 225 | Sr. | Courier | |
| 1993 | Conley | Todd | C | Sr. | Courier | Honorable Mention | ||
| 1993 | Cooper | Deke | WR | 6-1 | 185 | So. | Courier | Honorable Mention |
| 1994 | Cooper | Deke | WR | 6-3 | 200 | Jr. | Courier | Honorable Mention |
| 1995 | Cooper | Deke | RB | 6-3 | 206 | Sr. | Courier & Press | Player of the Year -- Both Papers |
| 1967 | Copeland | Roger | DB | 5-8 | 135 | Jr. | Courier & Press | Both papers + All SIAC |
| 1968 | Copeland | Roger | DB | 5-8 | 140 | Sr. | Courier & Press | Both papers + All SIAC |
| 1966 | Crowe | Eddie | DB | 5-10 | 135 | Sr. | Courier | |
| 1993 | Cuprisin | Andy | QB | Jr. | Courier | Honorable Mention | ||
| 1994 | Cuprisin | Andy | QB | Sr. | Courier | Honorable Mention | ||
| 1997 | DeBose | Jason | OG | 6-2 | 275 | Sr. | Courier | |
| 1968 | Dimmett | Dan | LB | 5-8 | 160 | Sr. | Courier | |
| 1971 | Dimmett | Paul | OG | 6-1 | 180 | Sr. | Courier | 2nd Team |
| 1994 | Dozier | John | DL | 6-2 | 225 | Sr. | Courier & Press | Courier-DL Press-OG |
| 1996 | Dubose | Jason | DT | 6-1 | 260 | Jr. | Press | |
| 1963 | Edwards | Gary | OT | 6-1 | 200 | Sr. | Courier | All SIAC |
| 1961 | Elmendorf | Byron | OE | 6-1 | 167 | Sr. | Courier | |
| 1995 | Ernspiger | Eric | OG | 6-1 | 270 | Sr. | Courier & Press | Both papers |
| 1980 | Erwin | Todd | QB | 6-0 | 165 | Jr. | Courier | 2nd Team |
| 1981 | Farmer | David | DB | 5-10 | 170 | Sr. | Courier & Press | Both papers |
| 1963 | Fenner | Lane | OE | 6-5 | 190 | Sr. | Courier & Press | Both papers + All SIAC |
| 2003 | Fisher | Justin | DL | 6-0 | 260 | Sr. | Courier | |
| 1972 | Fitch | Craig | OG | 5-11 | 175 | Sr. | Courier | |
| 1994 | Fox | Kenon | LB | 6-2 | 235 | Sr. | Courier & Press | Courier-LB Press-C |
| 1980 | Garland | Bryon | RB | 5-7 | 178 | Jr. | Courier | 2nd Team |
| 1981 | Garland | Bryon | LB | 5-8 | 175 | Sr. | Courier | 2nd Team |
| 1975 | Garrett | Cornell | RB | 5-9 | 142 | Jr. | Courier | |
| 1976 | Garrett | Cornell | RB | 5-9 | 142 | Sr. | Courier & Press | Both papers |
| 1979 | Garrett | Mark | RB | 5-7 | 155 | Sr. | Courier & Press | Both papers Unanimous Selection |
| 2009 | Garrett | Marcus | DL | 5-9 | 285 | Sr. | Courier | |
| 1979 | Garrett | Steve | OT | 6-0 | 250 | Sr. | Courier | 2nd Team |
| 2001 | Gewirtzman | Josh | DL | 6-2 | 290 | Sr. | Courier | |
| 1992 | Gibson | Rodney | DB | 6-0 | 172 | Sr. | Courier & Press | Both papers |
| 1971 | Gore | Jeff | DE | 6-0 | 175 | Sr. | Courier | |
| 2008 | Gott | James | WR | 5-9 | 155 | Sr. | Courier | |
| 1976 | Gray | Stoner | DB | 6-1 | 170 | Jr. | Press | |
| 1977 | Gray | Stoner | DB | 6-3 | 180 | Sr. | Courier & Press | DB - Courier WR - Press |
| 1992 | Grayson | Buster | DB | 6-2 | 195 | Sr. | Courier & Press | Courier-P Press-DB & P 35 yd avg |
| 1982 | Green | Brad | DB | 6-1 | 150 | Jr. | Courier | |
| 1983 | Green | Brad | DB | 6-1 | 165 | Sr. | Courier | |
| 1989 | Habermel | Jason | DE | 6-4 | 218 | Sr. | Press | |
| 1959 | Harrington | Herb | OG | 5-10 | 170 | Sr. | Press | Honorable Mention |
| 1975 | Hathaway | Rick | WR | 6-1 | 170 | Sr. | Press | |
| 1968 | Hawkins | Bob | OT | 6-2 | 197 | Sr. | Courier | |
| 1974 | Hawkins | Brent | K | 6-0 | 200 | Sr. | Courier & Press | K-Courier OG-Press Honorable Mention |
| 1975 | Herr | Dennis | QB | 6-1 | 170 | Sr. | Courier & Press | QB-Courier QB&DB-Press |
| 1963 | Hill | Ron | OC | 6-1 | 190 | Sr. | Courier & Press | Both papers + All SIAC |
| 1979 | Hobgood | Greg | DE | 6-0 | 170 | Jr. | Courier & Press | 1st team Press 2nd team Courier |
| 1980 | Hobgood | Greg | DE | 6-0 | 185 | Sr. | Courier | |
| 1996 | Holman | Aaron | OG | 6-2 | 230 | Sr. | Press | |
| 1989 | Huebner | Brian | QB | 6-1 | 155 | Jr. | Press | |
| 1990 | Huebner | Brian | P | 6-2 | 175 | Sr. | Press | |
| 1976 | Irvin | Stephan | LB | 6-1 | 205 | Sr. | Courier & Press | Both papers |
| 2007 | Jackson | Stephen | DB | 5-11 | 165 | Sr. | Courier & Press | |
| 1966 | Jesop | Ron | OT | 6-1 | 205 | Sr. | Courier & Press | Both papers Courier-Honorary Captain |
| 1981 | Jones | Robbie | WR | 6-0 | 175 | Sr. | Courier | 2nd Team |
| 1977 | King | John | QB | Sr. | Courier | Special Mention | ||
| 1980 | Kneer | Jeff | OG | 6-0 | 200 | Jr. | Courier | |
| 1981 | Kneer | Jeff | OT | 6-0 | 215 | Sr. | Courier | |
| 1962 | Kuhn | Keith | OE | 6-2 | 180 | Sr. | Press | Honorable Mention |
| 1983 | Lashbrooke | David | DL | Sr. | Courier | 2nd Team | ||
| 1973 | Lauer | Brian | WR | 6-0 | 165 | Sr. | Courier & Press | Courier-Hon. Mention Press-1st team |
| 1971 | Lawson | Mike | K | 5-10 | 175 | Sr. | Courier | |
| 2006 | Lewis | Jordan | DL | 6-3 | 260 | Sr. | Courier | IFCA 5A 1st Team All State |
| 1975 | Loehrlein | Keith | LB | 6-1 | 190 | Sr. | Courier | |
| 2004 | Lowery | Bryce | DB | 6-0 | 185 | Sr. | Courier | |
| 1962 | Mabrey | Joe | OG | 5-10 | 205 | Sr. | Press | Honorable Mention |
| 2000 | Madison | Anttonieo | DB | 5-10 | 195 | Sr. | Courier | |
| 1959 | Madriaga | Mike | HB | 5-5 | 145 | Jr. | Courier & Press | Both papers |
| 1960 | Madriaga | Mike | HB | 5-5 | 150 | Sr. | Courier & Press | Both papers |
| 1960 | Martin | Mickey | HB | 5-8 | 175 | Jr. | Press | Honorable Mention |
| 1961 | Martin | Mickey | QB | 5-8 | 180 | Sr. | Courier | Honorable Mention |
| 1959 | McAdams | Ron | OG | 5-11 | 170 | Sr. | Courier & Press | Courier-1st team Press-Hon Mention |
| 1979 | McCaslin | Chris | OT | 6-2 | 240 | Sr. | Courier | 2nd Team |
| 1987 | Merriweather | Carl | DB | 5-9 | 145 | Sr. | Courier | |
| 2007 | Merriweather | Larry | LB | 5-11 | 190 | Sr. | Courier & Press | |
| 1989 | Messel | Chad | DL | 5-10 | 226 | Sr. | Courier | |
| 1999 | Metz | Jacob | LB | 5-11 | 200 | Sr. | Courier | |
| 1994 | Miller | Andy | DB | Sr. | Courier | Honorable Mention | ||
| 1983 | Miller | Brad | LB | 6-1 | 180 | Jr. | Courier | |
| 1984 | Miller | Brad | LB | 6-2 | 190 | Sr. | Courier | Unanimous selection |
| 1998 | Miller | Jarad | OG | 6-3 | 250 | Sr. | Courier & Press | Both papers |
| 1998 | Miller | Mike | P | 6-3 | 180 | So. | Press | |
| 1960 | Mominee | John | HB | 5-8 | 142 | Sr. | Courier & Press | Both papers Honorable Mention |
| 1988 | Mooney | Ben | LB | 6-0 | 205 | Sr. | Courier & Press | Courier Def Player of the Year |
| 1998 | Neidlinger | Alex | TE | 6-3 | 210 | Sr. | Courier & Press | Both papers |
| 1995 | Neighbors | Kareem | QB | 5-11 | 172 | Sr. | Courier | |
| 1960 | Neumaster | Bill | OT | 6-2 | 175 | Sr. | Courier & Press | Courier-Captain Press-Hon Mention |
| 1982 | Niethammer | Darren | P | 6-2 | 180 | Sr. | Courier | 2nd Team |
| 2002 | O'Donnell | Kendall | RB | 6-1 | 175 | Jr. | Courier | |
| 2003 | O'Donnell | Kendall | RB | 6-1 | 180 | Sr. | Courier | All Metro Player of the Year |
| 2004 | Oswald | Chase | DE | 6-1 | 210 | Sr. | Courier | |
| 1966 | Padgett | Bill | LB | 5-10 | 150 | Sr. | Courier | |
| 1990 | Page | Bill | OT | 6-1 | 240 | Sr. | Press | |
| 1992 | Patterson | Alan | LB | 6-2 | 195 | Sr. | Courier | |
| 1995 | Patterson | Joe | LB | 5-11 | 222 | Sr. | Courier & Press | Both papers |
| 1977 | Paulson | Hank | DT | 5-11 | 188 | Sr. | Courier & Press | Both papers |
| 1977 | Pence | Steve | TE | 6-3 | 205 | Sr. | Courier & Press | Both papers |
| 1979 | Pendleton, Sr. | Dion | LB | 6-0 | 170 | Jr. | Courier | 2nd Team |
| 1980 | Pendleton, Sr. | Dion | LB | 6-0 | 173 | Sr. | Courier | |
| 2007 | Pendleton, Jr. | Dion | DB | 6-0 | 180 | Sr. | Courier & Press | AP 5A 1st team All State |
| 1977 | Pendleton | Mike | RB | So. | Courier | Honorable Mention | ||
| 1979 | Pendleton | Mike | DB | 6-2 | 170 | Sr. | Courier & Press | Both papers |
| 1982 | Pfingston | Brian | WR | 6-0 | 165 | Sr. | Courier | 2nd Team |
| 1960 | Pfingston | Larry | OG | 5-7 | 155 | Sr. | Courier | Honorable Mention |
| 1980 | Pitlick | Mike | RB | 5-8 | 175 | Jr. | Courier | 2nd Team |
| 2003 | Poag | Eric | OT | 6-3 | 235 | Jr. | Courier | |
| 2004 | Poag | Eric | OG | 6-4 | 265 | Sr. | Courier | |
| 2000 | Porter | Jared | OT | 6-2 | 280 | Sr. | Courier | |
| 1986 | Powers | Andrew | WR | Sr. | Courier | |||
| 1977 | Prange | Eric | WR | Sr. | Courier | Honorable Mention | ||
| 2001 | Raben | Nick | TE | 6-3 | 225 | Sr. | Courier | |
| 1971 | Raster | Dennis | DB | 5-11 | 158 | Sr. | Courier | |
| 1972 | Riat | Bill | RB | 5-11 | 170 | Sr. | Courier | Honorable Mention |
| 1963 | Riley | Morris | Coach | Courier & Press | Both papers + All SIAC | |||
| 1962 | Risch | Carl | OT | 6-2 | 200 | Sr. | Courier & Press | Both papers |
| 1963 | Risch | Mike | OT | 6-0 | 190 | Jr. | Courier | |
| 1964 | Risch | Mike | OT | 6-0 | 190 | Sr. | Courier | 2nd Team |
| 1964 | Rogers | John | HB | 5-10 | 165 | Sr. | Courier | Honorable Mention |
| 1971 | Sanders | Steve | DE | 6-3 | 194 | Jr. | Courier & Press | Courier-2nd team Press-1st team |
| 1972 | Sanders | Steve | LB | 6-3 | 200 | Sr. | Courier & Press | Courier-LB Press-End |
| 1974 | Schmidt | Jim | DB | 6-1 | 175 | Sr. | Courier & Press | DB-Courier QB-Press Honorable Mention |
| 1970 | Schrer | Ron | DT | 5-6 | 175 | Sr. | Courier & Press | Courier-DT Press-OG |
| 2003 | Scott | Mike | LB | 6-1 | 215 | Jr. | Courier | |
| 1962 | Skupas | Steve | OE | 6-3 | 187 | Sr. | Courier & Press | Both papers |
| 1989 | Smith | Scott | OG | 5-10 | 190 | Sr. | Courier & Press | Both papers |
| 2006 | Stewart | Brandon | WR | 6-0 | 180 | Sr. | Courier | !FCA Top 50 Selection |
| 1984 | Stewart | David | RB | 5-10 | 160 | Sr. | Courier | |
| 1980 | Summers | Thaddeus | DB | 6-0 | 170 | Sr. | Courier | |
| 2002 | Taylor | Lawrence | LB | 6-0 | 220 | Sr. | Courier | |
| 1959 | Taylor | Ron | OC | 5-9 | 165 | Sr. | Courier & Press | Courier-1st team Press-Hon Mention |
| 1975 | Theurkauf | Jon | OG | 6-0 | 195 | Sr. | Courier | |
| 1969 | Thomas | Jeff | LB | 5-11 | 175 | Jr. | Courier | |
| 1963 | Thomas | Jim | HB | 5-11 | 151 | Sr. | Courier & Press | Both papers + All SIAC |
| 1992 | Tomlinson | Taurus | OG | 5-11 | 225 | Sr. | Courier & Press | Both papers |
| 2007 | Todd | Quintez | DE | 5-11 | 225 | Sr. | Courier & Press | |
| 2003 | Upton | Mason | OG | 6-2 | 260 | Sr. | Courier | |
| 1963 | Volkman | Dean | QB | 6-0 | 175 | Sr. | Courier & Press | Both papers + All SIAC Courier MVP |
| 1960 | Volkman | Mike | QB | 6-0 | 175 | Sr. | Press | Honorable Mention |
| 1965 | Walker | Cleo | DG | 5-10 | 160 | Sr. | Courier | |
| 1971 | Wilkie | Jeff | LB | 5-11 | 170 | Sr. | Courier | |
| 1975 | Williams | Joe | OT | 6-3 | 245 | Jr. | Press | |
| 1976 | Williams | Joe | DT | 6-3 | 245 | Sr. | Press | |
| 1976 | Wilson | Kevin | P | 5-9 | 165 | Jr. | Courier | |
| 1977 | Wilson | Kevin | P | 5-9 | 165 | Sr. | Courier & Press | Both papers |
| 1995 | Wilson | Mike | Coach | Sr. | Courier | Coach of the Year | ||
| 1973 | Woodruff | Larry | DE | 6-1 | 190 | Sr. | Courier | |
| 1996 | Wright | Andrej | C | 6-2 | 230 | Sr. | Courier | |
| 1965 | Zehr | Dwain | OE | 6-2 | 175 | Sr. | Courier & Press | Both papers |